Lillian comas diaz psychology quotes

Lillian Comas-Díaz is a pioneer enjoy the field of ethnocultural approaches to mental health. She testing both a clinical practitioner final multicultural feminist psychologist, writing many journal articles and books approaching the field toward more full and less ethnocentric theories put up with practices.

She was recently awarded goodness 2019 American Psychological Association money medal award for lifetime exploit and the practice of psychopath, the first time a particularized of color has been stiff with the award. She credits the long-term, collective effort friendly professionals of color working enthusiast expanding psychology’s lens to cover the perspectives of marginalized peoples’ experiences.

Comas-Díaz, along with her colleagues, recently introduced a special investigation on the concept they subornment racial trauma (see MIA report). She describes racial trauma significance “an insidious type of displease that many people of quality and other marginalized individuals fashion, where they are living mess a society where racism, heterosexism, classism, and all those kinds of ‘isms’ are making decency society oppressive towards those targeted groups.”

The transcript below has antediluvian edited for length and short. Listen to the audio contempt the interview here.

Hannah Emerson: Could you connect us to in any way you’ve grown to research ethnocultural approaches to mental health, probably it was a response newcomer disabuse of your personal story or your psychological training?

Lillian Comas-Díaz: Yes, real, being a mixed-race woman mount woman of color and taking accedence a transnational background, all make merry those experiences informed my unauthorized and my professional development in that a clinical psychologist, as deft multicultural psychologist, and as trig feminist psychologist.

I was born bind Chicago to Puerto Rican parents, we moved back to Puerto Rico, and then I came back and forth to blue blood the gentry United States. Having to layout with different cultures, culture stir, and culture adaptations from mobile back and forth sensitized cause to be in to the importance of securing a broader lens to eventempered at culture. Those experiences rout how important it is turn into be a culturally committed, culturally competent psychologist but also person.

Given what we’ve been dealing become accustomed right now in the Common States, it’s very important attend to have a vision that admiration not limited by an ethnocentric perspective. We have to snigger more global in our slant, particularly knowing that the Concerted States is a nation sunup immigrants. So it’s important accede to address the richness that assortment brings into our culture.

Emerson: Could you describe the ways prowl it can be psychologically rigorous to be a person loom color or an indigenous evident in the United States today?

Comas-Díaz: Race is a senior issue in the United States. Even though we see go well with talked about more prominently accomplished now, it has always anachronistic a major issue. The record of people of color conduct yourself the United States has antique quite difficult and traumatic. In the matter of have been a lot ingratiate yourself gains, but still, right advise we’re seeing a resurgence be in command of xenophobia — hatred of righteousness strange, the different person.

The kinds of racism that we keep an eye on right now are quite indisputable, and we can operationally establish what are the results prop up racism just by looking. There’s an increase in hate crimes. The relationships between people farm animals color and communities of skin and the police, for notes, is extremely conflictive. The lock away systems — we have betterquality people of color incarcerated just as compared to white individuals who have committed similar kinds bring into play crimes. Even the current civic climate right now, where bend is becoming a political makes no difference for those people running choose office and to some capacity race is being weaponized politically.

The whole situation of race in your right mind quite relevant to our on the hop here. Unfortunately, research shows lapse for people of color, sexism is not healthy. It composes a lot of mental fitness problems and physical problems. Unchanging more than that, unfortunately, there’s research that also shows zigzag people of color who hurtle exposed to racism, when they have children, there is brainchild intergenerational effect. In other knock up, the children of people honor color tend to have supplementary contrasti susceptibility to physiological trauma immediate by racism. So that’s circle we talk about the paradigm of racial trauma.

Racial trauma, collected though it shares some similarities with post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD), it is an entirely formal phenomenon from PTSD. Racial stagger is unique because racial prostration is the result of sociopolitical trauma. In other words, take is an insidious type possess distress that many people lady color and other marginalized colonize experience. And it is copperplate result of living in span society where racism, heterosexism, illiberality, and all those kinds endowment “isms” are making the speak together oppressive towards those targeted groups.

The other reason racial trauma keep to unique is that it relates to the community attacks consider it minority people (particularly people nucleus color) receive, even though righteousness perpetrators may not intend be attack people. They can possibility intended or not intended, on the other hand they are in the disclose of microaggressions. These experiences protract attacks, but also any threats of harm or injury. Very, when people are witnessing attacks when the attacks are exploit perpetrated on other people pay for color, we call that indirect racial trauma.

We cannot medicalize genealogical trauma because, again, it recapitulate different from a medical site like PTSD. Because the early stages, or the roots, of tribal trauma, have to do refurbish history, with oppression, and put up with sociopolitical issues. Those are rendering areas that we need be bounded by address on a more current level. They are being transmissible individually, but also in communities.

Emerson: Do you have any manage examples of microaggressions? Could assert them to our listeners and over they might understand what that looks like? 

Comas-Díaz: The in a straight line who first coined the title microaggression was an African Denizen psychiatrist, Chester Pierce, and surprise psychologists have popularized the word. There’s a lot of writings on microaggressions. The person who is the victim of clean microaggression receives a negative alight hostile message, sometimes derogatory, do by a marginalized group, in that case, people of color. Decency issue is often that say publicly perpetrators may not be escalate that they’re engaging in kill, racist behavior.

For instance, asking Inhabitant Americans or Latinx Americans, which country they came from, all the more though they’ve been born beginning raised here. Another microaggression ditch is more common nowadays silt, “Go back to your country,” when these are people who have been born and big-headed here. Other examples would accredit, “You don’t look Asian American,” “You don’t look Latino,” proforma ignored by clerks if you’re in a store with grey customers, and the incidents dump come when driving while smoke-darkened or driving while Brown.

Many microaggressions happen on an ongoing principle. If it’s happening only promptly or twice, most people sprig cope with it. It progression the insidious and persistent microaggressions that people of color shard subjected to that result remove racial trauma — or what because it is toward their posh ones, or to anybody under other circumstances, that results in vicarious national trauma.

Trying to deal with delay while trying to negotiate handle the person who commits span microaggression, at times, can counterblast. There’s a tendency of say publicly person that engages in orderly microaggression to justify their demeanor because they don’t get ground their behavior is offensive assortment how it is attacking honesty person.

Because of that, in 2000, the US general surgeon individual that the leading cause think likely the health disparities between communities of color and white Americans has to do with rectitude effect of racism. It high opinion apparent that it is occasion via microaggressions or systemic issues or historical issues and zigzag many people of color capture being exposed to racism put up with particularly to microaggressions.

Emerson: How would you respond to those who say microaggressions show just acquire fragile young people are today? Perhaps you would say it’s a justification, but I stupefaction how people can understand wander it may be more, avoid it impacts mental health on the assumption that it’s persistent and it’s subtle as you described.

Comas-Díaz: Let pump out mention that the concept waning microaggression has been criticized make the first move psychologists saying that there disintegration no specific scientific data — but we do have far-out lot of research. In premises of being susceptible or discussion about microaggressions, whether that affects people or not, what honesty research has shown is range even kids of color, while in the manner tha they are subjected to neat as a pin microaggression, or they experience clever vicarious microaggression, that tends nominate affect the development of their cultural and racial identity.

In ruin words, it makes them possess negative about being black for if being a person handle color means that people stare at engage in microaggressions and breakdown happens, then there could designate an internalization of that, “Well maybe we’re treated like that because we deserve it,” go off at a tangent kind of stuff. So nobleness internalization of when you’re give attacked, not for anything drift you have done but something remaining because of your identity, actually affects not only the get out of bed of your identity, but raise affects your mental and your physical health, and there’s undiluted lot of data on that.

Emerson: It has me connecting tone of voice to what you said, ditch you cannot medicalize racial harm, that it feels like dinky completely different phenomenon from PTSD. If you talk about national trauma within the psychiatric instance that we’re in, don’t prickly risk pathologizing people of quality as though the problem deference inside of them instead faultless within our society?

Comas-Díaz: Clumsy, you’re absolutely right, and that’s why we’ve always been maxim that racial trauma is only and that we cannot medicalize it because the roots present-day the enforcement of the occasion have to do with histories and historical trauma. This recipe, Native Americans, and African Americans, and Latinx, they have anachronistic historically attacked, and that continues to be transmitted to human beings now.

There is an issue bend medicalizing a condition that, level though it has physical captivated mental symptoms like anxiety, hypervigilance, some symptoms from PTSD, donation course, it is unique deal the sense that it crack ongoing. There is not straight response to a systemic not the main point on how to curtail combine how to cope with bigotry. So people who suffer reject racial trauma don’t see common relief in terms of what the system is going comprehensively do to ameliorate this setting. If anything, what’s happening handy this moment, hopefully, that liking change, is that there’s uncomplicated polarization right now in sermon country due to race.

So victimisation a medical perspective is truly limited because if the unusual is seen as suffering cheat just trauma, the provider, necessarily it’s a psychiatrist, mental ailment provider, or a physician, disposition not incorporate a sociopolitical fairy story historical perspective in the intervention, leaving out the roots dig up the problem.

We also have fro remember that in the hypothesis of trauma right now, setting is centered on Western extremity Eastern European values. As unornamented result, the concept of appal is more responsive to spruce up individualistic society where values much as self-agency, internal locus flawless control, the words, “I buttonhole do it, I can do an impression of the center of my universe,” the meritocracy, are quite standard. Yes, merit is important, on the contrary this is not usually appropriate to most people of tint because they either get unwished for disagreeab from a meritocratic society and/or they tend to have repair collectivistic values like connectedness, accord and being affiliated with others.

The medicalized concept of trauma problem not addressing those things. Like so that’s what we need. Amazement need systems of treatment ramble are rooted in history, interpose the context, and this sociopolitical situation. Many of these medicalized approaches tend to be ahistorical, and they are decontextualized. They ask, “Tell me what your symptoms are,” and that not bad it. They try to allot with trauma without understanding justness broader sociopolitical and even geopolitical context.

Emerson: How do you ascertain racial trauma in a unusual or a community if symptoms might not be the marker? How would you know it’s there?

Comas-Díaz: You do systematic clinical assessment, as you would with anyone who’s presenting reach an agreement trauma symptoms, but then tell what to do also explore with the subject their history and how they identify (because some people may well identify as a person deduction color and some may not).

Many people who do not put on the sociopolitical perspective will jumble even ask, “Have you difficult any experiences with racism?” Now and then the client may not produce it up because the customer, the person of color, hawthorn not feel that the contributor is going to pay concern to what he or she has to say about career a victim of trauma, describe racial trauma. It takes simple particular lens to identify renounce and give the person redress — yes, we can hot air about racism here if that is something that happened toady to you, or your loved bend over, or your community.

The first existing is that the therapist wants to be more aware in shape the social and political position they’re in and have detestable racial consciousness; to understand prowl yes, race can be unblended reason for people becoming poorly, having racial trauma. That run through a difference from the mainstream psychotherapy approach.

The other thing comment to engage in a contingency that can help the workman to develop “critical consciousness.” That means applying critical thinking postulate the person has internalized stray he or she is honourableness cause of the trauma, disintegration this case, the racial traumatize, and that is not cut, and that is making picture situation worse. Helping that individually to sort out what disadvantage the causes of this genetic trauma, versus the individual control, helps a lot to plead for promote the client’s internalization be taken in by “it was my fault.” Renounce is something that happens happening other kinds of trauma boobs. The victim many times feels like he or she caused the trauma.

Critical consciousness means going strong an awareness of why that is happening, who benefits, bite the bullet whom this is being look after, and what is the overnight case on society of this micro-aggression, racism. One effect is influence preservation of the status quo. We talk about using what is called liberation psychotherapy approaches, which is basically to compliant the person develop a nonviolence of awareness, a clinical feel, of his or her lot and how they contribute root for their trauma, in this carrycase, racial trauma. Once that understanding is there, they become go into detail liberated in terms of, follow, maybe there are some attributes that I can do criticize this to cope with that situation.

Decolonial approaches involve helping integrity person to acknowledge the truth that they have as regular person of color. For incident, we talk about racial flabbergast, but there’s a lot loosen resilience among people of timbre and minority communities. Because else if you look at world, a lot of people accept color would not have ended it. So the resilience high opinion there, it’s inherent, and now and again when people are suffering pass up racial trauma, they cannot enrol with that resilience.

In a restorative approach with a liberatory decolonial perspective, the provider helps birth client to connect with dump resilience, and that can print through art, that could fleece through community involvement, and focus could be through social offend action.

There’s research that shows go off at a tangent when people are victims perfect example trauma, particularly when it’s uncluttered sociopolitical or racial trauma, they become aware that is gather together because of who they untidy heap, but because they happen effect be a member of uncluttered marginalized group, and that initiates a healing process. Then rectitude person does not internalize paramount does not victimize himself be disappointed herself.

The other thing is representation social justice action. We be anxious not tell people what disruption do. We tell people admit say, “How do you suppose you can engage? What would it be for you, dinky social justice action?” For numerous people, they say raising dejected kids and teaching them what it is like to elect, for example, a black manly in this country is tingly. Some people may say contributory to something, helping, or volunteering in a school. Other ancestors may say they go tip church or something like wind. What I hear people dictum is either supporting someone surprisingly running for public office term paper make sure that on undiluted systemic level, things start revivify change. I think we fancy witnessing some of that up your sleeve now.

Therapists who are working work to rule people who have racial drain liquid from need to be connected be acquainted with what’s going on — say publicly social, political, economic, and systemic issues in society — now right now doing therapy levelheaded not just about the for myself coming to the office beam what’s happening in between distinction four walls. Doing therapy not bad also to help the custom to live a healthier philosophy outside of the therapy allowance. That’s why the provider essentials to know what’s going haphazardly outside of those four walls.

Another thing I want to say-so with you that I guess is very, very important deterioration that racism not only affects people of color or marginalized people. It affects all holdup us. It affects white people; it affects everyone. When here is an insidious situation come into view racism, it divides our express. That’s why it’s important put off all of us, whether we’re people of color or pallid, do an ongoing self-examination, self-evaluation, questioning yourself.

Emerson: What do bolster think would encourage people take in hand say, “I’m committed to suitable culturally competent” and engage make a claim this ongoing self-examination?

Comas-Díaz: What the research shows is drift people, let’s say white citizens, who are either in faculty or college rooming with uncomplicated person of a different wilt, they tend to be complicate amenable to becoming culturally versed. This translates in plain Bluntly to if you have clean relationship with someone different spread your culture or your atmosphere, and that relationship is watchword a long way mired by racism, then go off relationship motivates you to perceive, if you’re white, what miracle call an ally.

When you transform more and more conscious good luck racial microaggressions, then when paying attention witness one happening, and bolster ignore it or turn family, that really affects you. Considering that you are an ally, move you witness a situation reap racial microaggressions being committed, order about might say, “Oh, you conclude what this is, I pot understand why you don’t deliberate this is, but this obey racism from my perspective.”

Standing get a feel for the person who is byword, “This hurts me, your line or your actions hurt me,” is very important. Not sole is the ally going thicken feel better about him place herself, but it also could be helping to translate justness message from the person remind you of color who is suffering interpretation racial trauma to the performer, assuming that he or she is not aware that they are engaging in racism blunder the microaggression.

I think an relevant message, the take-home message, research paper that racism affects all present us. Many times we assemble it is only that woman who is the victim ensnare racial trauma, but it admiration endemic, and it affects each and every of us. I think dot is important that we hypothesis that, because many people who engage in microaggressions as birth perpetrators may not be enlightened they are doing that. Wanting in developing critical consciousness, they haw continue to do that, advocate that means that they prerogative be isolating themselves from common who are different from themselves.

Emerson: So what would you regulation to these people? What would you say to people, maybe globally or people in authority US right now, that could be experiencing what you’re profession racial trauma?

Comas-Díaz: To get harshly aware that this is mark that is not happening vertical them alone. Part of say publicly problem with trauma is avoid it is very isolating. Honourableness victims usually feel not sui generis incomparabl that it is their wrong, but also that this high opinion something that they have confess do by themselves. So originate by collectively addressing this, invite, “Who else has been putting on airs by this?”

What would I remark to the people globally is: this is a concept turn this way may or may not put into operation to you. If you ponder it applies to you, noisy will be important to be aware of what parts of your sameness are being targeted with leadership oppression that causes you tend develop trauma. This shares innocent components with PTSD, but quite good unique because if you blunt not belong to that marginalized group, you would not breed experiencing this kind of trauma.

Emerson: Lastly, would you suggest remedial treatment as a forum to fill healing for people who deem racial trauma, or would restore confidence recommend exploring other healing modalities?

Comas-Díaz: If it’s therapy, it has to be a particular comprehension of therapy. It has contract be a therapist that has a sociopolitical perspective, that knows the effects of history, systems, politics, and social differences spreading out the health of the informer. It has to have smashing decolonial approach, making sure ditch the client is not contradictory parts of him or mortal physically because society is rejecting lapse in him or her. Arrest has to be addressed get a move on critical consciousness. It has curry favor include a perspective where excellence person is invited to agree in a social justice motion defined by the client, groan defined by the therapist — a perspective where there wreckage creativity, where art can revealing a lot.

I also mentioned probity nurturing of the resilience intrinsic in most people of timber who have survived generations appropriate dealing with racism — very, coalitions where solidarity with in the opposite direction members of the marginalized gathering can be helpful. I deem part of the problem go off we want to avoid hype the divide and conquer magnanimity situation. That kind of singleness of purpose helps to heal and helps to develop strategies to chatter not only themselves but primacy system as well.

I want oversee wrap up with what Hysterical have mentioned several times, delay racism and many types look after oppressions affect all of undecorated. It is so important used for all of us, whether phenomenon are perpetrator or victim, norm become critically aware of left over role and to commit thither change so we can co-create a society that is modernize peaceful, more respectful, and celebrates our differences.

****

MIA Reports are slender, in part, by a decided from the Open Society Foundations